More About the Science of Flying

The Coanda Effect, action and reaction

The short explanation for how the balloon stays aloft goes like this, from Dr. John Denker, an aerospace researcher and author: "The balloon and hairdryer demonstrate the Coanda effect, which is a very unusual and complicated phenomenon. It requires a narrow high-speed stream of air moving through slow-moving air and striking a curved surface. This causes lots of turbulent mixing, which produces a local decrease in pressure. The low pressure pulls up on the balloon and deflects the airstream downward."

The Coanda Effect: Thin streams of liquids and gases bend around curved objects.

If you take a balloon, cup, or any round object to the kitchen sink and put the side of it under a stream of water, the water will bend around the object. This is called the Coanda effect.
The stream of air is thrown downward

Although the Coanda Effect is easy to see with water, it also applies to thin streams of fast-moving air--such as what comes out of a hair dryer. When it gets to the curved balloon, it bends around. By the time it parts with the balloon, the air is going downward! It is important to note here that some kind of force has to be acting on the air to make it bend. Sir Isaac Newton's First Law of Motion explains that.

This brings us to Sir Isaac Newton's Third Law of motion, which states that for every action, there is an opposite reaction. The classic example is air rushing out of a balloon (action) and the balloon streaking ahead (reaction).

It is tempting to try to use the flight of the balloon to explain how airplanes fly, but it's a limited analogy. It is true that both explanations involve low-pressure areas, fast-moving air diverted down and reactive lift, but then they diverge. The balloon uses a thin stream of very turbulent air, while an air flowing over a wing is smooth, and air far above the wing is affected.

As Dr. John Denker cautioned, "...trying to explain how wings work in terms of the Coanda effect is like trying to explain walking in terms of bowling. Your hair drier and balloon makes a fine gee-whiz activity -- just please don't leave folks with the impression that it is a close analogy to how wings work. Bowling involves many of the same muscle groups as walking, but it is more complicated and more specialized. The jet of high-speed air coming out of the hairdryer has no analog in ordinary flight. Of course general statements about Newton's third law apply equally well to walking, bowling, wings, and balloons."

The Atomizer

Here's another neat demonstration of the Coanda effect: the atomizer. Instead of lifting a balloon, it lifts water. The air stream then nebulizes the water into a spectacular spray.

You'll need a cup, tape, a couple of straws and a suitable place. Outside is an obvious choice, but blowing the mist into a shower/bath stall or a dishwasher works too.

Start by taping a piece of straw to the inside of a dry cup with one end sticking up about 1/2" above the rim. Fill the cup full with water. If the cup is dry and you have pressed the tape on hard, it should keep sticking for awhile even under water.

Now blow hard across the top of the vertical straw with another straw, positioned horizontally as shown in the illustration. The fast air stream creates a low-pressure area that draws the water to the top of the straw and blasts it into a spray as it comes out. This sort of thing finds a practical application in air brushes, which spray paint, and in carburetors, which mix gasoline with air for small engines.

I'd like to know how this project goes for you. I'm happy to answer questions about it. Feedback from you is an important way for me to know what works and what needs clarification.

How to Make the Floating, Spinning Balloon

Note: If you want a very quick, easy project, you can stop after the first two steps. The balloon won't spin, but it will float.

What You Need

  • Round balloon
    Look at a discount store like Walmart in the section where they sell birthday party supplies. If there is more than one size of round balloon, get the bigger size.
  • Hair dryer with long nose
    The hairdryer has to be the kind with the long front nozzle--as shown in the picture--so the air stream is well directed. Unfortunately, this style is hard to find these days. Perhaps a store that specializes in barber supply products would have them. A vacuum cleaner hooked up the wrong way so it blows out air instead of sucking it in might work. I have not tried a leaf blower yet, but that might work.
  • Tape, string, pennies, ruler
    You can use dental floss, thread, or whatever for string
  • Optional
    Scissors, marker, paper

STEP 1: Inflate the balloon, attach string and weight.

  1. Inflate and tie off a round balloon.
  2. With about a foot of string, tie one end of the string to the balloon.
  3. Tape one or two pennies to the other end of the balloon. With one penny, the balloon hovers farther from the hair dryer. With two pennies it is more stable. You can fly it right now, although it won't spin yet.

STEP 2: Fly the balloon

Set the hairdryer for minimum heat. Experiment with the air-flow setting. High flow flies the balloon farther away. Low flow might allow more stable flight.

Start flying the balloon above the hair dryer. Then you can slowly tilt more and more so the balloon will hover farther away.

STEP 3: Start laying out the tape-turbine locations.

The small, angled tape protrusions will spin the balloon. This step and the next are optional, but helpful, especially the first time for getting the tape evenly on the balloon. That makes it more stable. It also provides a learning opportunity for kids as the balloon is divided into hemispheres, quarters, then eighths.

With the balloon oriented as shown, use a magic marker to draw an "equator." I have never been able to draw a decent looking line. It has not hurt the performance, but if you want it to look good, try this: Wrap a long strip of paper or a sheet of newspaper around it and trace on the edge.

STEP 4: Finish laying out tape-turbine locations.

Now draw two meridians perpendicular to the equator and to each other. The illustration shows a side view, the right side shows how it looks from the top.

STEP 5: Make the tape-turbine pieces.

Cut off a one and one-half inch piece of tape and fold it as shown. The middle will stick together, but fold one quarter inch of each end out so they do not stick to each other.

I always mangle half of the tape, and even the best are not quite right. The balloon still spins great. If you really hate working with tape, try cutting and folding plain paper strips, then stick them to the balloon with a glue stick or tape.

Step 6: Stick tape-turbine blades onto balloon.

Stick on one piece of formed tape (or paper) at each of the equator / meridian intersections, angled about forty-five degrees from vertical. They all have to slant the same way. The right illustration shows a close-up view.The balloon might spin now with just the four turbine blades. Try it, remembering that you still need the string and one penny attached.

STEP 7: Stick on more turbine blades if needed

Stick four more tape blades on the balloon in between the tape already there, as shown.The balloon should spin quickly and fly with more stability than when it was not spinning.

To see an even more stable design, as well as activities to do with the spinning balloon, go to the following steps.

STEP 8: If the balloon seems too wobbly, replace the string and weight with a paper tube (optional).

Use an ordinary 8 1/2" by 11" sheet, and roll it up so it is long (11"). Roll it tightly enough that the wall of the tube has two layers, which will make it about 1 1/4" in diameter. Tape the tube so it holds its shape.

STEP 9: Tape paper roll to bottom of balloon.

Tape the paper tube onto the bottom of the balloon

Tape it on the underside so it is exactly centered on the outlet of the balloon, with four pieces of tape.

Now try flying it (no need for the penny now) If you got it centered it should be more stable.

Put a cup on the edge of a table and try to land in the cup. It's not easy, is it? It makes me appreciate how difficult and dangerous it must be to land a helicopter in turbulent wind.

 

I'd like to know how this project goes for you. I'm happy to answer questions about it. Feedback from you is an important way for me to know what works and what needs clarification.

The Floating, Spinning Balloon

Floating, spinning balloon with hair dryer. There is no helium, but it flies!

It's almost eerie, the balloon floating in space and spinning furiously like some spacecraft out of a science fiction story! Pointing the hairdryer -- it doesn't even have to be directly under the balloon -- gives you remote control to hover and land. It's quick and easy to make, too.

I'd like to know how this project goes for you. I'm happy to answer questions about it. Feedback from you is an important way for me to know what works and what needs clarification.